The Carnivalesque Rebellion Issue

Do You Do Nothing or Do You Resist?

And if you did not fight, would you see yourself as noble? Or cowardly?
WIKILEAKS.CH / AHMAD MASOOD (REUTERS)

Audio version read by George Atherton – Right-click to download

I say to every red-blooded American, every European, every human: If someone comes into your home, threatens your family, imprisons and even kills your family what do you do? I do not care if every Westerner of any station is afraid to say it, it is part of my purpose in life to say it: I would fight. In fact I would kill before I would allow my family to be harmed. I would fight to the death.

I say to my American brothers and sisters in particular: Can you not see that the Iraqis, the Afghanis and the Palestinians are people? They are mothers and fathers, uncles and aunts, brothers and sisters and sons and daughters. They love their family every bit as much as you. Imagine that you were in their shoes. Would you be passive? Would you sit by and watch your wife and child being violated? Or would you fight?

I want every reader of this article to come on a journey with me. We are in our home. We are brothers, poor in terms of money but rich in our love of family. We love each other as brothers do. Our wives are in the kitchen preparing food for our children. We do our best, poor and impoverished, surrounded by war brought in the form of occupiers from halfway around the world. The sound of rifle butts banging on the door shatters the semblance of peace. You, my brother, go to the door quickly, but not quickly enough. The door slams open and the soldiers from another land come storming in.

With weapons pointed at our heads, they shout orders which we believe tell us to put our hands on our heads and get down on our knees. We are not sure, English is a language brought to us, not our mother tongue. Our wives come to the room frightened, begging the soldiers to calm down for the sake of the children in the other room. The soldiers respond by shouting at our wives and pushing my wife to the ground with their assault rifles. Our hearts are racing; our manhood is being crushed; and we wonder if we are men at all.

The shouting and the chaos increase. Next comes the sound of your baby girl. You hear her crying for her mother. You imagine her look: terrified. Thinking of your little baby girl you feel tears on your face. You look at your wife; she is now on the ground, bleeding from where the rifle butt slammed into her head. In the chaos you do not even know when this happened. The soldiers begin throwing all that we own everywhere, overturning furniture, throwing papers and family items to the ground and breaking dishes. They ransack while one demands to know our names. As soon as I say my name they grab me and take me into the next room, the room between you and our children. They begin to beat me, mercilessly. They are shouting at me, but you do not know what they are saying.

Now all the children are crying frantically, the soldiers keep yelling and you catch the word “terrorist.” You realize that they are calling me, your brother who you have known your whole life, a “terrorist.” I plead with them to stop the beating, blood drenching every inch of my face, for the sake of the children, who are by now screaming, crying and begging for their mom and dad, I beg. All you can think to do is nothing: You are paralyzed. And eventually the soldiers take me away … You will never hear from me again.

Your children are alive, for now, and your wife will survive, but she is scarred. Your sister-in-law is without her husband; you are without your brother; your parents are without their son and the children are without a father. You find out later that “someone” gave your brother’s name to the soldiers as a “terrorist.”

And so you ponder, do I do nothing or do I resist?

This is a scenario of war/occupation. It is not extreme – it is inherent. Indeed we could include scenarios where wives and daughters are raped in front of husbands and fathers. You think Americans do not do this? You are wrong. War makes everyone crazy; the question is to what degree. Insanity is inherent in war. The folly of chanting “Support the troops!” while sending them off to bullshit wars could not be more stark.

And so I ask: If you came from the lands we invade, would you fight? And if you did, would you see yourself as a “terrorist”? Or a man?

And if you did not fight, would you see yourself as noble? Or cowardly?


Ken O’Keefe, worldcitizen.uk.net

40 comments on the article “Do You Do Nothing or Do You Resist?”

Displaying 21 - 30 of 40

Page 3 of 4

WashMachine

Correct...we can write tough and talk tough and claim we know what we would do ourselves..but can we really know?

The terror being inflicted upon the innocent is heinous and violent retaliation is expected...but isn't this exactly what the corporate warmongers want? Isn't an illegal American Invasion exactly what the terrorists want?

If we were all for violent resistance where would we all be?

And why stay so vague with a notion as broad as "violence" there is violence in many natural things...our beating hearts, sex, the death of a star, etc... The shock of violence can at times create the needed pause to gain perspective yet this is never the case with violence against life.

The action of violence against life brings a temporary change but in time will return the troubles tenfold. As we will sadly experience in the years to come in America....

WashMachine

Correct...we can write tough and talk tough and claim we know what we would do ourselves..but can we really know?

The terror being inflicted upon the innocent is heinous and violent retaliation is expected...but isn't this exactly what the corporate warmongers want? Isn't an illegal American Invasion exactly what the terrorists want?

If we were all for violent resistance where would we all be?

And why stay so vague with a notion as broad as "violence" there is violence in many natural things...our beating hearts, sex, the death of a star, etc... The shock of violence can at times create the needed pause to gain perspective yet this is never the case with violence against life.

The action of violence against life brings a temporary change but in time will return the troubles tenfold. As we will sadly experience in the years to come in America....

Anonymous

It is never too late for non-violent action, but there is no excuse for apathy or inaction. Resistance need not be violent to be powerful.

Anonymous

It is never too late for non-violent action, but there is no excuse for apathy or inaction. Resistance need not be violent to be powerful.

rattlebone

A population tortured by years of cruel sanctions, untold lives lost, all basic infrastructures destroyed by continuous air attacks, invaded and occupied by foreign troops,civilians murdered in their beds, imprisoned and disappeared. Millions of women, children and elders slaughtered, wounded and displaced.

I'm uncertain as to how the author would respond to your question, "Are you suggesting shooting at an American or any soldier, is sometime a good idea?"

Yeah, a necessary and damn good one at that.

rattlebone

A population tortured by years of cruel sanctions, untold lives lost, all basic infrastructures destroyed by continuous air attacks, invaded and occupied by foreign troops,civilians murdered in their beds, imprisoned and disappeared. Millions of women, children and elders slaughtered, wounded and displaced.

I'm uncertain as to how the author would respond to your question, "Are you suggesting shooting at an American or any soldier, is sometime a good idea?"

Yeah, a necessary and damn good one at that.

rattlebone

A population tortured by years of cruel sanctions, untold lives lost, all basic infrastructures destroyed by continuous air attacks, invaded and occupied by foreign troops,civilians murdered in their beds, imprisoned and disappeared. Millions of women, children and elders slaughtered, wounded and displaced.

I'm uncertain as to how the author would respond to your question, "Are you suggesting shooting at an American or any soldier, is sometime a good idea?"

Yeah, a necessary and damn good one at that.

rattlebone

A population tortured by years of cruel sanctions, untold lives lost, all basic infrastructures destroyed by continuous air attacks, invaded and occupied by foreign troops,civilians murdered in their beds, imprisoned and disappeared. Millions of women, children and elders slaughtered, wounded and displaced.

I'm uncertain as to how the author would respond to your question, "Are you suggesting shooting at an American or any soldier, is sometime a good idea?"

Yeah, a necessary and damn good one at that.

Anonymous

I'm sorry Wash Machine, but your questions--Fight who? Fight how?--are more obtuse than zen koan...it may be too late to just wish our oppressors would be nice and just listen to us, but that time has past. Iime now to take to the streets and take real action

Anonymous

I'm sorry Wash Machine, but your questions--Fight who? Fight how?--are more obtuse than zen koan...it may be too late to just wish our oppressors would be nice and just listen to us, but that time has past. Iime now to take to the streets and take real action

Pages

Add a new comment

Comments are closed.