Thought Control in Economics

The Delusion Revolution

The future we have been dreaming of is not based on reality.
The Delusion Revolution
Mike Mills, Let's Be Human Beings, 2003, Photo: Todd Cole

This article is available in:

Imagine you are riding comfortably on a sleek train. You look out the window and see that the tracks end abruptly not too far ahead ... The train will derail if it continues. You suggest the train stop immediately and the passengers go forward on foot. This will require a major shift in everyone’s way of traveling, of course, but you see it as the only realistic option. To continue barreling forward is to court catastrophic consequences. But when you propose this course of action, others – who have grown comfortable riding on the train – say, “We like the train, and arguing that we should get off is not realistic.”

In the contemporary United States, we are trapped in a similar delusion. We are told that it is “realistic” to yield to the absurd idea that the systems we live in are the only systems possible or acceptable based on the fact that some people like them and wish them to continue. But what if our current level of first world consumption is exhausting the ecological basis for life? Too bad. The only “realistic” options are those that view this lifestyle as nonnegotiable. What if real democracy is not possible in a nation-state with 300 million people? Too bad. The only “realistic” options are those that view this way of organizing a polity as immutable. What if the hierarchies our lives are based on are producing extreme material deprivation for the oppressed and dull misery among the privileged? Too bad. The only “realistic” options are those that view hierarchy as inevitable.

Let me offer a different view of reality:

(1) We live in a system that, taken as a whole, is unsustainable – not only over the long haul but in the short term.

(2) Unsustainable systems cannot be sustained.

How’s that for a profound theoretical insight? Unsustainable systems can’t be sustained. It’s hard to argue with that. The important question is whether or not we live in a system that is truly unsustainable. There’s no way to definitively prove such a sweeping statement, but look around at what we’ve built and ask yourself whether you really believe this world can go forward indefinitely … or even for more than a few decades. Take a minute to ponder the end of cheap fossil energy, the lack of viable large-scale replacements for that energy and the ecological consequences of burning what remains of it. Consider the indicators of the health of the planet: groundwater contamination, topsoil loss, levels of toxicity. Factor in the widening inequality in the world, the intensity of the violence and the desperation that so many feel at every level of society.

Based on what you know about these trends, do you think this is a sustainable system? If you were to let go of your attachment to this world, is there any way to imagine this as a sustainable system? Considering all the ways you understand the world, is there anything in your field of perception that tells you we’re on the right track?

The important question is whether or not we live in a system that is truly unsustainable.

To be radically realistic in the face of all this is to recognize the failure of basic systems and to abandon the notion that all we need to do is recalibrate the institutions that structure our lives. The old future – the way we thought things would work out – truly is gone. The nation-state and capitalism are at the core of this unsustainable system, giving rise to the high-energy/mass-consumption configuration of privileged societies that has left us saddled with what James Howard Kunstler calls “a living arrangement with no future.” The future we have been dreaming of is not based on reality. Most of the world’s population – who don’t live with our privilege – has no choice but to face this reality. It’s time for us to come to terms with it.

Robert Jensen is a journalism professor at the University of Texas at Austin. He is the author of Getting Off: Pornography and the End of Masculinity and All My Bones Shake: Seeking a Progressive Path to the Prophetic Voice.

150 comments on the article “The Delusion Revolution”

Displaying 141 - 150 of 150

Page 15 of 15

Anonymous

is coming to a theater near you...
greed, adictions, delusions, hallucinations, greed, greed, glutony, uy, sounds like one of those sins. extreme capitalism is sucking people out, people that thought they had something to live off. like a rice farmer in india who suddenly cannot compete with the major corps. forget ipod, berries, think soil, seeds, waiting for the rains.
next time you visit a shop place a sticker on crap "do you really need this?" and make the consumer think about it. attacks aren't worth it, defense systems are the rule of the day. it's what made rumsfeld. weapon makers exists on the premise of defense. who are the major weapon makers? usa, russia, uk, germany - it begins there, catch 22.

Anonymous

is coming to a theater near you...
greed, adictions, delusions, hallucinations, greed, greed, glutony, uy, sounds like one of those sins. extreme capitalism is sucking people out, people that thought they had something to live off. like a rice farmer in india who suddenly cannot compete with the major corps. forget ipod, berries, think soil, seeds, waiting for the rains.
next time you visit a shop place a sticker on crap "do you really need this?" and make the consumer think about it. attacks aren't worth it, defense systems are the rule of the day. it's what made rumsfeld. weapon makers exists on the premise of defense. who are the major weapon makers? usa, russia, uk, germany - it begins there, catch 22.

Anonymous

is coming to a theater near you...
greed, adictions, delusions, hallucinations, greed, greed, glutony, uy, sounds like one of those sins. extreme capitalism is sucking people out, people that thought they had something to live off. like a rice farmer in india who suddenly cannot compete with the major corps. forget ipod, berries, think soil, seeds, waiting for the rains.
next time you visit a shop place a sticker on crap "do you really need this?" and make the consumer think about it. attacks aren't worth it, defense systems are the rule of the day. it's what made rumsfeld. weapon makers exists on the premise of defense. who are the major weapon makers? usa, russia, uk, germany - it begins there, catch 22.

Anonymous

is coming to a theater near you...
greed, adictions, delusions, hallucinations, greed, greed, glutony, uy, sounds like one of those sins. extreme capitalism is sucking people out, people that thought they had something to live off. like a rice farmer in india who suddenly cannot compete with the major corps. forget ipod, berries, think soil, seeds, waiting for the rains.
next time you visit a shop place a sticker on crap "do you really need this?" and make the consumer think about it. attacks aren't worth it, defense systems are the rule of the day. it's what made rumsfeld. weapon makers exists on the premise of defense. who are the major weapon makers? usa, russia, uk, germany - it begins there, catch 22.

Brandon, Canada

I think as long as we have this left, right, liberal, communist hooblah we'll get no where. does it matter what we class ourselfs as? i mean is there even such thing as liberal? communist? i don't know, and i'll never know. neither will anyone wasting there time talking about it. screw where your from, or what side you place yourself at. find a solution as people, nothing more. if you put trust in history you'll see history is history beucase it's GONE, just like we will be if we continue caring about the wrong thing. false belief can drag you down, self examination is key. i don't know what the answer is, and who is anyone saying they do? we should spend more time showing youth the truth, i myself am 18 and i feel like everything i read, am told, or hear about is total bullshit. you want change? progress? give me and other youth an education that will show me the real world. i'm ranting aren't i? haha god damn youngsters!! bahaha
ll

Brandon, Canada

I think as long as we have this left, right, liberal, communist hooblah we'll get no where. does it matter what we class ourselfs as? i mean is there even such thing as liberal? communist? i don't know, and i'll never know. neither will anyone wasting there time talking about it. screw where your from, or what side you place yourself at. find a solution as people, nothing more. if you put trust in history you'll see history is history beucase it's GONE, just like we will be if we continue caring about the wrong thing. false belief can drag you down, self examination is key. i don't know what the answer is, and who is anyone saying they do? we should spend more time showing youth the truth, i myself am 18 and i feel like everything i read, am told, or hear about is total bullshit. you want change? progress? give me and other youth an education that will show me the real world. i'm ranting aren't i? haha god damn youngsters!! bahaha
ll

spatterprint

Thinking about the chart on population expansion in the print, I can't help but sense the train wreck looming ahead of us as the greatest sacrifice of life, human and/or otherwise ever. OK so we're on track for the #6 spot but since when will 'merika stand for being the sixth best at anything without rallying the troops to at least try for #1? I agree that after this singular event, (the manifestation of peak everything?) it will be notable if anyone still adheres to the left/right dichotomy or if anyone remembers the architects of this disaster (e.g the politicians, economists, the pop stars who distract us &/ make us feel satiated that we've watched the right movies/read the right books or captains of industry). Can't help but think again to the call of the survivalist wilds. I usually discount population arguements in favor of class based consumption arguements, but it's coming, the track is running out and all of our petty squabbling over semantics isn't going to mean shit(at least no one will have the luxury to get so petty over it). Just remember the humans defending the train, egging the conductor to full speed, at some deep subconscious level are doing their best to bring the moment of reason to bear as quickly as possible and as efficiently as possible. Typical misguided type-A personalities I guess... Can't tell them anything.

spatterprint

Thinking about the chart on population expansion in the print, I can't help but sense the train wreck looming ahead of us as the greatest sacrifice of life, human and/or otherwise ever. OK so we're on track for the #6 spot but since when will 'merika stand for being the sixth best at anything without rallying the troops to at least try for #1? I agree that after this singular event, (the manifestation of peak everything?) it will be notable if anyone still adheres to the left/right dichotomy or if anyone remembers the architects of this disaster (e.g the politicians, economists, the pop stars who distract us &/ make us feel satiated that we've watched the right movies/read the right books or captains of industry). Can't help but think again to the call of the survivalist wilds. I usually discount population arguements in favor of class based consumption arguements, but it's coming, the track is running out and all of our petty squabbling over semantics isn't going to mean shit(at least no one will have the luxury to get so petty over it). Just remember the humans defending the train, egging the conductor to full speed, at some deep subconscious level are doing their best to bring the moment of reason to bear as quickly as possible and as efficiently as possible. Typical misguided type-A personalities I guess... Can't tell them anything.

Pages

Add a new comment

Comments are closed.