Whither Canadian Democracy?

To Kick-and-scream, or whimper?

If you drop a frog in a pot of boiling water, it will jump out as fast as it can. But if you place it gently in a pot of cool water, and turn the heat on low, it will float there quite serenely. As you gradually heat the water up, the frog will be further subdued, exactly as one of us would be in a hot bath. And before long, with a smile on its face, the frog will unresistingly allow itself to be boiled to death.

Do we Canadians suffer from the Frog-in-Boiling-Water syndrome? As our democracy erodes in the hands of Stephen Harper, we don't react. Rather than demanding justice and democracy like the Egyptians are doing . . . as hundreds upon thousands of them flood the streets, screaming for what they know they deserve. . . we wait silently, or whimper softly, as our democratic freedoms slip away . . . and before we know it . . . it's too late.

Harper has promised to change Canada beyond recognition: what we are famous for - Rocky mountains, pristine oceans, glacial rivers and lakes, old growth forests, beavers, maple trees - are all just data in Harper's "resource development" mission a.k.a his environmental-apocalypse mission. He will turn Canada into a barren landscape with nothing but criss-crosses of pipelines - and he will do so without hesitation or conscience. And the 39% who voted for him will have to explain to their children and grandchildren, the role they played in the destruction of this country.

On December 4, 2012, Canada has 2.5 million protected rivers and lakes. As of December 5th, we now have just 82 protected rivers and lakes, thanks to the contentious changes done to the Navigable Waters Protection Act in Harper's latest, rushed-in omnibus bill.

Just a week after introducing it, the Canadian government is hastily pushing through another omnibus bill (C-45). Among some of the really manipulative maneuvers you can find in the bill, one of the worst is the "changes to land management on aboriginal reserves" that it seeks to put forward - of course without consulting First Nations leaders themselves, and physically restraining them when they tried to come forward in protest.

According to Article 18 of the UN Declaration of Indigenous Peoples, First Nations peoples in Canada "have the right to participate in decision-making in matters which would affect their rights, through representatives chosen by themselves in accordance with their own procedures, as well as to maintain and develop their own indigenous decision-making institutions."

With Bill C-45, the voices of First Nations leaders are being muffled, ignored and censored in decisions that affect their treaty rights and land. This is an imperialist act of violence and a violation which illustrates that the federal government has neither respect nor basic regard for First Nations peoples. But such is our history . . . "Canada" muffling, ignoring, censoring, murdering, criminalizing these people. As this latest proposition of the Harper administration goes through, much of the public remains in the dark about the real, dirty, genocidal history of the founding of Canada -'cause it sure isn't taught to us in grade school! And through bills like these, the brutality of our colonial legacy continues in full force.

And this aggressively colonialist government of ours humiliated us last week with it’s recent vote against Palestine’s status at the UN – but this shouldn’t come as a surprise considering the hawkish, militant stance of our foreign policy as of late, forsaking our once eminent peacekeeping stature. No better than our neighbors to the south, our government too is in bed with dozens of corporations. Rather, our government is the oil industry. They've walked all over us, now they trample us - but we barely peep.

If this were a functioning democracy, it would require our participation - for us to say "no" when we feel it, and to say it until we are heard. Look at footage of Egypt, as violent as it is, that is what it looks like when a real democracy is struggling to be born. Hundreds of thousands are shouting and fighting in the streets . . . and over what? . . . Over the fine print in the drafts of a constitution. Mea Culpa! As Harper does the same thing, we order another latte. Wither our revolutionary fervor and democratic dynamism?

Our resistance exists but it is weak and divided. We can't see that we are all on the same team. We love to cherry-pick fights and hate on each other instead of directing that anger where it is needed. We love to argue over tactics and ideological rhetoric instead of moving from our guts in urgency to defend what is being stolen from us in the blink of an eye. But above all, we're too comfortable . . . even as the water in the pot gets hotter.

Adbusters 111 Cover

On Newsstands December 3

At last we’re in Winter. It’s the year 2047. A worn scrapbook from the future arrives in your lap. It offers a stunning global vision, a warning to the next generations, a repository of practical wisdom, and an invaluable roadmap which you need to navigate the dark times, and the opportunities, which lie ahead.

Subscribe to Adbusters Magazine

Comments on the article “Whither Canadian Democracy?”

Displaying 1 - 10 of 10

Page 1 of 1


I think harper should adopt the song sung by tim curry from fern gully as his theme song. He should play it before every speech he makes. Hell, i'd vote for him...
"Oil and grime...poison sludge
Diesel clouds and noxious muck
Slime beneath me...slime up above
Ooh you'll love my (ah-ah-ah) toxic love."

Joshua Norton

Boiled frog analogy is wrong. Try it out. Most creatures have the capacity to detect when homeostasis is not being maintained. They try and jump out.

And wanting to replace reasoned debate with riots and groups actively fighting in the streets? Okay, you've lost me.

Martin Lampert

What reasoned debate? Was there actually a serious debate on this matter over which the public had any sway or influence??

Get real

Anonymous student

We as canadians need a unified call of resistance against our government. Who will provide this call?
I hope that someone out there or adbusters will provide what I and our nation need, a call to protest and demonstrate against our ruthless government.


There's more: Last week, Harper had Agonquin Park in Northern Ontario completely paved over with asphalt.

It took 478,000,000,000,000,000,000 metric tonnes of asphalt, but he did it.

He's gonna turn the entire Algonquin Park into a giant pulp and paper mill, and feed the rest of the trees in Canada into it. He's gonna sell all the paper to the US treasury who are gonna print currency out of it to keep capitalism alive.


It has been sad watching Canada descend into the Conservative abyss of stupid,by their exemplary election system.Apparently the people of Canada are ready to lose their long held reputation for tolerance and Democracy,personal liberties,leading the free world to the future,no more.The Conservative paranoia,spending on war tools,and intrusive security (actually insecurity) ,a hallmark of the Conservatives,suits the people of this once proud democracy,now sliding into the abyss of stupidity the hallmark of Conservative policies.Sad indeed eh?


Algonquin Park is PROVINCIAL not FEDERAL. I doubt they are paving any more than the main road in, which would be welcome to anyone who has driven there.

Add a new comment

To comment or reply please Log In, Create An Account or post as Anonymous.