Panache!
AP Photo/The Times-Picayune, Matthew Hinton
My three-year-old son’s favorite book is Out of the Blue. It has large color photographs of sea animals, from plankton to clownfish to orcas. I often find my son, dressed in his pajamas, on the floor of his bedroom in the morning carefully turning the pages of the book. And every time I hear him naming out the magnificent creatures before him, my heart breaks. Within my son’s lifetime, if there is not a radical reversal in human behavior, the oceans of the world, and the life systems they support, will die.
I fight for my children. It is not about me. It is about them. The deep despair I feel over our collective inability to acknowledge, much less confront, the catastrophic dislocations ahead of us is offset by a fierce desire as a father to make sure I have summoned all my energy and resilience to defy the corporate systems of death that are exploiting human beings and the natural world until their exhaustion or collapse. At least, I hope, my children will look back and see that their father did not remain passive as the ecosystem was destroyed in the name of profit, and the world was reconfigured by corporations into a terrifying neofeudalism, a kind of totalitarian capitalism. At least they will see, I hope, pictures of their father being hauled off to jail in defiance. I resist not out of hate but out of love, a love for all the things the deformed culture of corporate profit finds meaningless and sentimental – children, lakes, mountains, trees and the song of a wood thrush deep in the forest.
The consequences of severe climate change are unavoidable. The freak weather patterns, the wild fires and tornadoes sweeping across Midwestern states, along with the droughts and severe flooding in China, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Australia, along with the soaring temperatures across the Earth, are upon us. And this is only the start. But what is most frightening is that the rapid and terrifying acceleration of global warming, which is disfiguring the ecosystem at a swifter pace than even the gloomiest scientific studies predicted a few years ago, have been met with collective denial and self-delusion. Global temperatures have already gone up one degree and begun the rapid melting of the Arctic. Every rise of one degree Celsius means a ten percent reduction in grain yields. If we stopped all carbon emissions today temperatures would continue to rise by at least a degree, perhaps more. A sudden epiphany would not save us from drastic climate change, large scale human migrations, rising sea levels, famine and endemic food shortages. Welcome to our brave new world.
The only viable option to save the human species from self-immolation – ending our dependence on fossil fuels – is ignored by the industrialized world’s power brokers, who have shredded the tepid climate agreement made at Kyoto. The last thin hope for reform and reversal will come through sustained acts of civil disobedience and open defiance of the formal systems of power. It means getting arrested. This is the conclusion drawn by many of our most prescient and important voices, including Wendell Berry and Bill McKibben.
Working within the system to reform it has failed. Working outside the system to defy it may also fail. Let’s be honest about this. The corporate structures of power are indifferent to the needs, rights or desires of the ordinary citizen – not to mention the planet – and have hijacked all systems of power from mass communications to electoral politics to the courts.
It is understandable that a realist would despair. And if I was to retreat into self-absorption I would find a small plot of land where I would never have to hear another leaf blower, and find what comfort I could in my family, my books and the whispers and beauty of the natural world. But to give up is not morally permissible. It is to condemn, as Sitting Bull reminded us, the born and the unborn, as well as the flora and fauna, which Sitting Bull also considered sacred, to misery and death. We have no right to do that. We must stand and fight for life.
We must fight for those who come after us, for those who at this moment are too small, too weak and too disempowered to fight, for the born and the unborn, for those who, like my son, have not yet lost the capacity for wonder and awe before the natural world. We owe our children that. The hardest moral stance and the greatest act of courage will be to see clearly, like Sitting Bull, the darkness and the power of the forces of death arrayed against us and yet find the fortitude to resist. Sitting Bull’s greatest fear at the end of his life was that he had not fought hard enough for his people and that they might revile him.
Resistance preserves our personal dignity as autonomous human beings. It means we have not allowed ourselves to be classified as objects. It is a way to defy our obscurity. Life is short. We all die. Nearly all battles for justice will long outlive us. I find my solace in faith. It is not the faith of any orthodox creed or religion but the faith that we are called to do the good, or at least the good in so far as we can best determine it, and then to let it go. We do not know where this good goes or if it goes anywhere. The Buddhists call this good karma. But faith means that acts of resistance – for true spirituality is always about resistance – are never meaningless, although all tangible signs may point toward failure and defeat. This faith gives me great comfort.
It is the faith that Cyrano de Bergerac expressed as he lashed out in his final battle, a battle he knew he could not win. Mortally wounded and facing Death, he suddenly rises. “Not here! Not lying down!”
His friends spring forward to help him. “Let no one help me,” he tells them as he props himself against a tree. “Only the tree … Let the old fellow come now! He shall find me on my feet, sword in hand … ”
“What’s that you say?” Cyrano calls out to the darkness. “Hopeless? Why, very well! But a man does not fight merely to win! No! No, better to know one fights in vain! … You there, who are you? A hundred against one. I know them now, my ancient enemies: Falsehood! There! There! Prejudice, Compromise, Cowardice!”
He swings with his sword. “What’s that? No! Surrender? No! Never, never! Ah, you too, Vanity! I knew you would overthrow me in the end. No! I fight on! I fight on! I fight on!”
He stops, breathless and dying. “Yes, all my laurels you have riven away And all my roses; yet in spite of you, There is one crown I bear away with me, And tonight, when I enter before God, My salute shall sweep all the stars away From the blue threshold! One thing without stain, unspotted from the world, in spite of doom. Mine own!”
He springs forward, his sword aloft.
“And that is … ”
The sword falls from his hands. He totters and falls into the arms of Roxane and his friends.
“That is … my panache.”
278 comments on the article “Panache!”
Displaying 31 - 40 of 278
Page 4 of 28
Anonymous
you are undeniably disgusted, but why? why are you so angry at this protest that you need to come to this forum in attack mode? if, as you obviously believe, there is no serious problem worth protesting, and the protesters are all... babies, idiots, [fill in the blank]s, then... it would follow that "right" (as demonstrated by you) will prevail (as much because "right" has the "might" as the (presumed) ignorant incompetence of the protesters which will cause them to fail) and, in the meantime, there will be a relatively mild disruption (of no serious consequence compared to many other "occupations") while a bunch of "fools" shoot their mouths off.
I think I can understand why you disagree (probably better than you), I'm just wondering why you are so bothered that you physically type and post your instigating comments, and what you hope to accomplish by doing so. here's a bit of friendly advice: if you have any particular points you'd like to make, you would do better to phrase them in a much more diplomatic way at this particular site, considering not only that you are a guest here, but (more importantly, I'm sure you'll agree) also, many of the viewers may be undecided as to whether or not they want to support the movement. you could very well be having an effect that is quite the opposite of what you intended. (let's play fair *smile*)
Anonymous
you are undeniably disgusted, but why? why are you so angry at this protest that you need to come to this forum in attack mode? if, as you obviously believe, there is no serious problem worth protesting, and the protesters are all... babies, idiots, [fill in the blank]s, then... it would follow that "right" (as demonstrated by you) will prevail (as much because "right" has the "might" as the (presumed) ignorant incompetence of the protesters which will cause them to fail) and, in the meantime, there will be a relatively mild disruption (of no serious consequence compared to many other "occupations") while a bunch of "fools" shoot their mouths off.
I think I can understand why you disagree (probably better than you), I'm just wondering why you are so bothered that you physically type and post your instigating comments, and what you hope to accomplish by doing so. here's a bit of friendly advice: if you have any particular points you'd like to make, you would do better to phrase them in a much more diplomatic way at this particular site, considering not only that you are a guest here, but (more importantly, I'm sure you'll agree) also, many of the viewers may be undecided as to whether or not they want to support the movement. you could very well be having an effect that is quite the opposite of what you intended. (let's play fair *smile*)
Anonymous
Interesting reply. Would you classify me as a guest on your website the same way you would classify the people illegally infesting our public parks as guests? I should hope you understand why I disagree with your movement. I work, pay taxes and dislike it very much when people who do neither insist that I give up more of what I earn because they are unable to find success in life. And yes, I will take the time to physically type and post unpleasant comments, just as you and your ilk will take the time to chant and shout and deface public property in an attempt to make me feel guilty about how I live my life. I'm curious, who will pay for the cleanup of the "relatively mild disruption" Won't be you guys, you made the mess. As usual, it'll be us taxpayers. Unfortunately for you, this website serves as a forum for your crackpot movement so you best be prepared to take the heat when you go after the people who actually produce in this country. One last question, would the protestors be in "attack mode" if they stormed the homes and offices of CEO's as many of your fellow comrades have advocated? As I posted earlier, if you want change, do it at the ballot box. This is America, not Egypt or Libya, and whining and crying in the streets will only bring about disgust and disdain for your pathetic movement. As your comrades in Chicago would gesture, Twinkles Down Man.
Anonymous
Interesting reply. Would you classify me as a guest on your website the same way you would classify the people illegally infesting our public parks as guests? I should hope you understand why I disagree with your movement. I work, pay taxes and dislike it very much when people who do neither insist that I give up more of what I earn because they are unable to find success in life. And yes, I will take the time to physically type and post unpleasant comments, just as you and your ilk will take the time to chant and shout and deface public property in an attempt to make me feel guilty about how I live my life. I'm curious, who will pay for the cleanup of the "relatively mild disruption" Won't be you guys, you made the mess. As usual, it'll be us taxpayers. Unfortunately for you, this website serves as a forum for your crackpot movement so you best be prepared to take the heat when you go after the people who actually produce in this country. One last question, would the protestors be in "attack mode" if they stormed the homes and offices of CEO's as many of your fellow comrades have advocated? As I posted earlier, if you want change, do it at the ballot box. This is America, not Egypt or Libya, and whining and crying in the streets will only bring about disgust and disdain for your pathetic movement. As your comrades in Chicago would gesture, Twinkles Down Man.
Anonymous
interesting reply. *wink* actually, this is not "my" website. I am just as much a guest here as you. and I would like to point out two things. first, how do you figure that the people protesting don't pay taxes? I would assume that they've paid all the taxes required based on their level of income and commercial consumption. unless you're suggesting they're all criminals. and second, regarding the mess they're creating, the "infestation" of "public parks" - have you considered: what kind of "mess" is left behind at every single football game, parade, air show, shopping mall, anywhere massive groups of people collect? the protesters are not filthy - they're human. what else can they do that is both proactive and impacting?
also, you said something extremely relevant, although I'm not sure you realize just how much so. "they are unable to find success in life". what a callous and casual way to phrase what so many of the protesters are going through, and have been going through for years. I don't suppose you'd feel you were simply "unable to find success in life" if you were out of work for more than six months, lost your home, struggled to feed your children on a daily basis... a "mess" can be cleaned up, the protest is not creating the same level of destruction as happens regularly with floods, fires, and the like. please try to remember that there are more than two levels: (really good / really bad).
one more thing: I couldn't help but notice that you stated that the protesters were "attempting to make you feel guilty about how you live your life". I can't understand why you would feel that the protesters are personally directing their frustration at you. their protest is not about you. if you are feeling "guilty", that's on you, mate.
Anonymous
interesting reply. *wink* actually, this is not "my" website. I am just as much a guest here as you. and I would like to point out two things. first, how do you figure that the people protesting don't pay taxes? I would assume that they've paid all the taxes required based on their level of income and commercial consumption. unless you're suggesting they're all criminals. and second, regarding the mess they're creating, the "infestation" of "public parks" - have you considered: what kind of "mess" is left behind at every single football game, parade, air show, shopping mall, anywhere massive groups of people collect? the protesters are not filthy - they're human. what else can they do that is both proactive and impacting?
also, you said something extremely relevant, although I'm not sure you realize just how much so. "they are unable to find success in life". what a callous and casual way to phrase what so many of the protesters are going through, and have been going through for years. I don't suppose you'd feel you were simply "unable to find success in life" if you were out of work for more than six months, lost your home, struggled to feed your children on a daily basis... a "mess" can be cleaned up, the protest is not creating the same level of destruction as happens regularly with floods, fires, and the like. please try to remember that there are more than two levels: (really good / really bad).
one more thing: I couldn't help but notice that you stated that the protesters were "attempting to make you feel guilty about how you live your life". I can't understand why you would feel that the protesters are personally directing their frustration at you. their protest is not about you. if you are feeling "guilty", that's on you, mate.
Anonymous
Guess what mate, I dont at all feel guilty about how I live my life. Your protest becomes about me when someone who doesn't produce insists that I give up more and more of what I earn. As for the messes left behind at the venues you stated, cities hold these events because they realize revenue will be generated from people attending. I think its safe to say that the vermin who have camped out illegally in our public parks have generated absolutely zero dollars to local businesses, but instead have actually cost them money. After all, I'm sure the protestors feel their entitled to use a private business owners restroom facilities. As far as paying taxes, I'm sure your pals pay a sales tax just as everyone else does, but maybe you can tell me how much in income taxes an out of work person would be paying if he has no income. Why dont all of you slugs just be honest and say what you want. You want to take money from working people and you want it redistributed to people who dont work, plain and simple. And by the way, if a protester has been unable to find work and in dire straits for years, perhaps that protestor should examine his own life and put the blame on himself and not the system.
Anonymous
Guess what mate, I dont at all feel guilty about how I live my life. Your protest becomes about me when someone who doesn't produce insists that I give up more and more of what I earn. As for the messes left behind at the venues you stated, cities hold these events because they realize revenue will be generated from people attending. I think its safe to say that the vermin who have camped out illegally in our public parks have generated absolutely zero dollars to local businesses, but instead have actually cost them money. After all, I'm sure the protestors feel their entitled to use a private business owners restroom facilities. As far as paying taxes, I'm sure your pals pay a sales tax just as everyone else does, but maybe you can tell me how much in income taxes an out of work person would be paying if he has no income. Why dont all of you slugs just be honest and say what you want. You want to take money from working people and you want it redistributed to people who dont work, plain and simple. And by the way, if a protester has been unable to find work and in dire straits for years, perhaps that protestor should examine his own life and put the blame on himself and not the system.
Anonymous
I honestly feel sorry for you. and I don't mean that in a condescending way. I believe that that is how you see this situation. I understand what you're saying and, sure, it should make sense and would make sense if it were that simple. I don't suppose you've ever been out of work for more than six months. It can happen to anyone, not just people who made bad decisions. (rich people make bad decisions, too - hence occupywallstreet)
just how much could they be "taking" from you in taxes? is it too much? aren't you left with plenty enough to live comfortably? how much do you think you're worth? (I'm asking rhetorically... fyi)
you're personally frustrated. that much is clear. can't you understand the frustrations of the protesters? they're not worried about losing "some", they're worried about not getting "some". they're not trying to find money, they're trying to find work, fair work. people shouldn't need 3 jobs to get by because they don't have a "profession". don't you know ANYONE in such a situation?
Anonymous
I honestly feel sorry for you. and I don't mean that in a condescending way. I believe that that is how you see this situation. I understand what you're saying and, sure, it should make sense and would make sense if it were that simple. I don't suppose you've ever been out of work for more than six months. It can happen to anyone, not just people who made bad decisions. (rich people make bad decisions, too - hence occupywallstreet)
just how much could they be "taking" from you in taxes? is it too much? aren't you left with plenty enough to live comfortably? how much do you think you're worth? (I'm asking rhetorically... fyi)
you're personally frustrated. that much is clear. can't you understand the frustrations of the protesters? they're not worried about losing "some", they're worried about not getting "some". they're not trying to find money, they're trying to find work, fair work. people shouldn't need 3 jobs to get by because they don't have a "profession". don't you know ANYONE in such a situation?
Pages
Add a new comment