The Ecopsychology Issue

Environmental Jihad

Is a holy war against the five-planet lifestyles of the West Justified?
Photo by Justin Guariglia - National Geographic
Photo by Justin Guariglia - National Geographic

April 19 – 25 is Digital Detox Week. Here’s some inspiration for your digital cleanse.


In January 2010, as the war against terrorism dragged into its ninth year, the ideological leader of the mujahideen issued a statement that could have been drafted by any Western environmentalist: “Talk of climate change isn’t extravagant speculation: It is a tangible fact that is not diminished by its being muddled by some greedy heads of major corporations.” Osama bin Laden then declared that “there must be accountability and punishment for those who head the major corporations and their political proxies, so that they stop their harmful actions against humanity.”

Hearing the “enemy” express sentiments so similar to our own inner thoughts is challenging. The momentum of environmentalism is stalling, co-opted by industrialists selling the toxic cleaning agents for their own pollutants and by celebrity politicians who smile for paparazzi while sabotaging global accords. Bin Laden’s words breathe a new sense of intensity and potency into a complacent movement because behind his rhetoric – which sounds so much like our own – are terrifying deeds.

Environmentalism has always had a militant shadow. It is apparent in the seminal works of Edward Abbey, whose oeuvre encompasses nature writing at its most philosophically profound (Desert Solitaire), obstinately righteous (Fire on the Mountain) and passionately violent (The Monkey Wrench Gang). The last, of course, inspired the formation of Earth First! and continues to inform sporadic Earth Liberation Front actions. But until now environmental militancy has been minimal, recruitment constrained by its bourgeois Western origins.

Bin Laden’s clarion call changes all that. It marks the beginning of a holy war against the West that many Western environmentalists may come to endorse. Post-Copenhagen it is clear that our nominally democratic society is under the sway of a corporatist, obstructionist oligarchy whose fat cats will jettison any sustainable vision of the future if it hurts their bottom line. And therein lies the significance of bin Laden’s speech: While one can argue divisively about the Israeli occupation of Palestine, the potential for democracy in the Middle East and the viability of alternatives to capitalism, it is both unarguable and unifying that humanity is hurtling toward a precipitous climate catastrophe.

It is, of course, a highly suspect proposition that anyone in good conscience could rally behind bin Laden. He has blood on his hands that can never be washed off, no matter how green the water. And with a political biography eerily reminiscent of Emmanuel Goldstein from George Orwell’s 1984, one must wonder whether bin Laden is actually dead, a creation of the CIA or simply the pseudonym for a group of jihadist writers. The importance of bin Laden’s words, however, is not what they portend for his future but what they suggest for ours.

There seem to be two possible scenarios that could prevent civilization’s collapse. One is that we continue the scientific-materialist project: Embrace geoengineering wholeheartedly and hope that an entirely unnatural synthetic world can save us. The other possibility – and the one that seems increasingly likely – is that a charismatic member of the mujahideen will arise to deliver a challenge that resonates with the materially poor and the spiritually wealthy of every nation of the world.

And when that happens, we will look back on the day we were first exposed to bin Laden’s environmental plea and know that it was the beginning of a new era of solidarity between those who have rejected consumerism and the five billion others who never had a choice.

Micah White is a contributing editor at Adbusters and an independent activist. He lives in Berkeley, CA and is currently writing a book about the future of activism. www.micahmwhite.com or www.junkthought.org

86 comments on the article “Environmental Jihad”

Displaying 31 - 40 of 86

Page 4 of 9

Anja

Your article has a decidedly self-indulgent American perspective. The issue of radical fundamental religion are not even mentioned. Islam has conquered the world before, as has Christianity. Islam means to again, all with kind words and a smile on their faces, just like the fat cats and corporate gorillas. Your article is not informative but rather incredibly naive, and if bin Laden has power it is only fueled by the ignorance of people who pay attention to his false words. Hitler was a friend of the people as well, his words were full of sentiment, that people of that time related to. He was a hero to masses of Germans because he pretended to care for and have a solution for the rampant unemployment of the day, and then he deftly high-jacked them and the world, in their need and disillusionment, spreading insanity across the face of the world. To draw any parallels between bin Laden and his words, which are formed to simply manipulate the disenfranchised, angry and, what you seem to think, even the conscious of the world is truly wrong.

The world is in a mess I agree. Holy war is a scam and has nothing to do with good values, even though their words are sympathetic. Wake up. This is adbusters isn't it? Look up the definition for psychopath. Your article is written showing only your pissed off point of view and doesn't even try to deal with facts. Educate yourself and then truly write to inform, if you truly care and are as passionate as you seem.

It still shocks me that many Americans are so disengaged. I hope you try to see a bigger picture, because if this is what you think, you are in a dark room stumbling around.

Anja

Your article has a decidedly self-indulgent American perspective. The issue of radical fundamental religion are not even mentioned. Islam has conquered the world before, as has Christianity. Islam means to again, all with kind words and a smile on their faces, just like the fat cats and corporate gorillas. Your article is not informative but rather incredibly naive, and if bin Laden has power it is only fueled by the ignorance of people who pay attention to his false words. Hitler was a friend of the people as well, his words were full of sentiment, that people of that time related to. He was a hero to masses of Germans because he pretended to care for and have a solution for the rampant unemployment of the day, and then he deftly high-jacked them and the world, in their need and disillusionment, spreading insanity across the face of the world. To draw any parallels between bin Laden and his words, which are formed to simply manipulate the disenfranchised, angry and, what you seem to think, even the conscious of the world is truly wrong.

The world is in a mess I agree. Holy war is a scam and has nothing to do with good values, even though their words are sympathetic. Wake up. This is adbusters isn't it? Look up the definition for psychopath. Your article is written showing only your pissed off point of view and doesn't even try to deal with facts. Educate yourself and then truly write to inform, if you truly care and are as passionate as you seem.

It still shocks me that many Americans are so disengaged. I hope you try to see a bigger picture, because if this is what you think, you are in a dark room stumbling around.

Ken Vallario

i agree with your criticisms of religious fanaticism...
i thought however, the writer was quite clear about the dangers of letting such a powerful agenda, such as the environment be co-opted by a psychopath...i thought that was the whole point of the article...
although, i see that this can be seen a bit as Western indulgence, as it seeks to arouse a competitive spirit...but a little bit of passion for unified ingenuity might not be a bad thing right now...
i resist the value of patriotism, but i equally resist what i will call anti-patriotism, the uniform disdain for a country, as it commits the same logical error, of personifying an artificial mental construct. America, is an abstract generality that is only moderately useful as a word...like all countries, it is constructed of a great diversity of individuals, so to critique this article as 'american' is to avoid a more sophisticated rebellion against his claims.

Ken Vallario

i agree with your criticisms of religious fanaticism...
i thought however, the writer was quite clear about the dangers of letting such a powerful agenda, such as the environment be co-opted by a psychopath...i thought that was the whole point of the article...
although, i see that this can be seen a bit as Western indulgence, as it seeks to arouse a competitive spirit...but a little bit of passion for unified ingenuity might not be a bad thing right now...
i resist the value of patriotism, but i equally resist what i will call anti-patriotism, the uniform disdain for a country, as it commits the same logical error, of personifying an artificial mental construct. America, is an abstract generality that is only moderately useful as a word...like all countries, it is constructed of a great diversity of individuals, so to critique this article as 'american' is to avoid a more sophisticated rebellion against his claims.

mrsituationist

"The other possibility – and the one that seems increasingly likely – is that a charismatic member of the mujahideen will arise to deliver a challenge that resonates with the materially poor and the spiritually wealthy of every nation of the world."

that's the other possibility? Really? btw how is parading around calling feminism the cause for earthquakes qualify as "spiritually wealthy?" How about employing an massive class of spiritual leaders to tell you how to act?

Hurray for identity politics hypocrisy!!!

Interesting that the environmental fringe is completely reasonable concerning the expertise of scientists about climate change and then completely rejects their expertise when it comes to transforming our economy as "consumerist materialism"....

Sorry but supporting efforts to make my truck that I enjoy driving free of fossil fuels (and that you mooch rides from everytime you have to move your shit that doesn't fit on your bicycle) does not = killing pandora.....

mrsituationist

"The other possibility – and the one that seems increasingly likely – is that a charismatic member of the mujahideen will arise to deliver a challenge that resonates with the materially poor and the spiritually wealthy of every nation of the world."

that's the other possibility? Really? btw how is parading around calling feminism the cause for earthquakes qualify as "spiritually wealthy?" How about employing an massive class of spiritual leaders to tell you how to act?

Hurray for identity politics hypocrisy!!!

Interesting that the environmental fringe is completely reasonable concerning the expertise of scientists about climate change and then completely rejects their expertise when it comes to transforming our economy as "consumerist materialism"....

Sorry but supporting efforts to make my truck that I enjoy driving free of fossil fuels (and that you mooch rides from everytime you have to move your shit that doesn't fit on your bicycle) does not = killing pandora.....

ken vallario

this comment and the one above made me read the article again, and they are good criticisms...the two possibility approach does indeed narrow the field beyond reasonable measure...good work...

ken vallario

this comment and the one above made me read the article again, and they are good criticisms...the two possibility approach does indeed narrow the field beyond reasonable measure...good work...

nic

those two little tid bits sound like undercover agents who want us to keep living this way, for an intelligent thought go one down past me to Anja, screw those three above me in the ear with a hot chopstick... nothing but people who wish they were doing something productive for the world and instead of starting, take out their subconscious frustration in counterproductive and ignorant little nodes of blah.

both of you fags and belong frozen drifting suffocated in the vacuum. (i don't mean homosexuals, those people are cool... i mean, the old meaning, the end of a cigarette)

nic

those two little tid bits sound like undercover agents who want us to keep living this way, for an intelligent thought go one down past me to Anja, screw those three above me in the ear with a hot chopstick... nothing but people who wish they were doing something productive for the world and instead of starting, take out their subconscious frustration in counterproductive and ignorant little nodes of blah.

both of you fags and belong frozen drifting suffocated in the vacuum. (i don't mean homosexuals, those people are cool... i mean, the old meaning, the end of a cigarette)

Pages

Add a new comment

Comments are closed.