Blackspot

Authentic Revolt

In search of authenticity.

Tom McCarthy's debut novel, Remainder, is a brilliant exposition of our collective loss of authenticity. The story is told from the perspective an unnamed character who suffers a bizarre accident and receives several million dollars in compensation. With this financial windfall the protagonist funds a series of "reenactments." He hires teams of actors who recreate his memories and experiences on a constant loop while he sometimes watches and other times participates. The goal, as he explains it, is to experience a feeling of authenticity -- to go through the motions of life as if they were intuitive, perfect and natural. The result is a novel that reveals the pervading sense of inauthenticity that haunts the twenty-first century.

If the catch-phrase of the late twentieth century was Holden Caulfield's "phony," then our century may be best described as "inauthentic." Whereas phony designates a way of being that is superficial, inauthentic refers to a type of existence which is unreal. Of course, McCarthy was not the first to offer this description -- as early as 1927, Martin Heidegger used authentic/inauthentic as definitions of what it means to be human. For Heidegger, however, and in contrast with McCarthy, the experience of inauthenticity comes when one's self is lost in the bustle of life. In Being and Time Heidegger explains that inauthenticity occurs when we "have lost ourselves in the everydayness of existing among things and people". This position, which appeared misanthropic to some, led to a rejection of Heidegger's diagnosis.

What McCarthy offers, however, is a different interpretation of inauthenticity. In his novel, the main character's reenactments progress from acting out memories to experiences to future events. In the beginning of the novel, the protagonist spends hours practicing how to move around a kitchen counter and open a refrigerator perfectly, as if he were in a movie. And one of the final reenactments is a bank heist, where after going through the motions of a robbery repeatedly in an artificial environment, the reenactment becomes suddenly real and authentic. For McCarthy, the twenty-first century experience of inauthenticity is no longer losing ourselves in the bustle of everydayness, but is instead a basic aspect of life where our media worlds offer a level of reality that we no longer experience for ourselves.

What is most striking about McCarthy's novel, and the reason why I'd suggest culture jammers read it, is because of the political implication of our inauthentic existence. Oftentimes it feels as if our protests are merely reenactments. We go through the motions, chanting, locking arms all the while feeling unreal. And we confound the situation by confusing the symptoms of revolution (broken windows, people getting arrested, marches in the street) with the causes of revolution. But just because we are reenacting the protests of May 1968 does not mean that we are authentically experiencing a revolutionary moment.

McCarthy's work offers a way to think though this problem. And although he offers no concrete solutions, his novel puts forth the profound conclusion that the greatest challenge for culture jammers today may be how to regain a feeling of insurrectionary authenticity.

Micah White is a Contributing Editor at Adbusters and an independent activist. He lives in Berkeley, CA and is currently writing a book about the future of activism. www.micahmwhite.com or www.junkthought.org

18 comments on the article “Authentic Revolt”

Displaying 11 - 18 of 18

Page 2 of 2

Purkerson

It will come when the majority of (Gen Y) college graduates refuse to work for corporations (mcdonz, etc.) and instead want to work for environmental causes( planting trees,forestry, communal projects). The whole corporate system will collapse when all its youth labor ( ie. the educated) and all its CEO labor ( ie. retired/dying babyboomers) ceases to hold up the capitalist infastructure...

Fund more tree planting youth! We want to do it- we have able bodies and able minds ( focused on friendship and nature and health- not profit necessarily...) The values will clash and when Gen Y realizes that were all sitting together in cubiles we hate ( with no boss around?) Then whats going to happen?

Purkerson

It will come when the majority of (Gen Y) college graduates refuse to work for corporations (mcdonz, etc.) and instead want to work for environmental causes( planting trees,forestry, communal projects). The whole corporate system will collapse when all its youth labor ( ie. the educated) and all its CEO labor ( ie. retired/dying babyboomers) ceases to hold up the capitalist infastructure...

Fund more tree planting youth! We want to do it- we have able bodies and able minds ( focused on friendship and nature and health- not profit necessarily...) The values will clash and when Gen Y realizes that were all sitting together in cubiles we hate ( with no boss around?) Then whats going to happen?

Anonymous

My students seem to believe that their own actions and thoughts only have credence if they fall into a category that has been established by the media. The media defines authenticity. Your own life does not matter; your favorite actor's life does, because it is in the media. It is in the news. It is real. An image on a screen is far more solid, more approachable, and easier to believe in than a nebulous idea. But those ideas, hard to put into words, hard to plan and execute, hard to explain and probably impossible to fully achieve, are as authentic as dreams.

Anonymous

My students seem to believe that their own actions and thoughts only have credence if they fall into a category that has been established by the media. The media defines authenticity. Your own life does not matter; your favorite actor's life does, because it is in the media. It is in the news. It is real. An image on a screen is far more solid, more approachable, and easier to believe in than a nebulous idea. But those ideas, hard to put into words, hard to plan and execute, hard to explain and probably impossible to fully achieve, are as authentic as dreams.

NBNG

revolution is about changing how you/we live, when gore and damage become the signposts of revolution that's when its inauthentic

NBNG

revolution is about changing how you/we live, when gore and damage become the signposts of revolution that's when its inauthentic

Pages

Add a new comment

Comments are closed.