Adbusters

Bill McKibben on Idle No More

Does the future of the planet rest in this movement?

NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC

As Stephen Harper and a delegation of Canadian First Nations Chiefs went into a highly anticipated meeting last Friday, Bill McKibben penned this bold and haunting article. McKibben paints a real clear picture of #Idlenomore as the immmune system of our ailing planet – a movement with greater scope and power than many are realizing. It is nothing less than our only hope.

How so?

Answer: Alberta's tar sands continue to be hailed as the "dirtiest energy on earth," the most environmentally destructive project we've ever seen. NASA's James Hansen explains that burning this bitumen guarantees "game over for the climate." Which means, to McKibben, "Canada's First Nations are in some sense standing guard over the planet." As he explains:

The stakes couldn't be higher, for Canada and for the world. Much of this uprising began when Canada's Prime Minister Stephen Harper rammed through Parliament an omnibus bill gutting environmental reviews and protections. He had no choice if he wanted to keep developing Canada's tar sands, because there's no possible way to mine and pipe that sludgy crude without fouling lakes and rivers. (Indeed, a study released a few days ago made clear that carcinogens had now found their way into myriad surrounding lakes). And so, among other things, the omnibus bill simply declared that almost every river, stream and lake in the country was now exempt from federal environmental oversight.

Canada's environmental community protested in all the normal ways – but they had no more luck than, say, America's anti-war community in the run up to Iraq. There's trillions of dollars of oil locked up in Alberta's tarsands, and Harper's fossil-fuel backers won't be denied.

But there's a stumbling block they hadn't counted on, and that was the resurgent power of the Aboriginal Nations. Some Canadian tribes have signed treaties with the Crown, and others haven't, but none have ceded their lands, and all of them feel their inherent rights are endangered by Harper's power grab. They are, legally and morally, all that stand in the way of Canada's total exploitation of its vast energy and mineral resources, including the tar sands, the world's second largest pool of carbon. NASA's James Hansen has explained that burning that bitumen on top of everything else we're combusting will mean it's "game over for the climate." Which means, in turn, that Canada's First Nations are in some sense standing guard over the planet.

15 comments on the article “Bill McKibben on Idle No More”

Displaying 11 - 15 of 15

Page 2 of 2

JPierre33

Yes, there is not much depth to your reasoning - natural resources in this country should belong to ALL Canadians - this is far from being so due to greed and corruption on levels so far beyond those of past history. How about the government and corporations being accountable for all negative impacts to lands and cultures? The little demagogue' has been using 'rent seeking' ploys in his bills (c-38 and c-45) which are totally treasonous. The little demagogue' needs to be incarcerated for treason ASAP.

anonymous

When we all finally admit WE are part of the tarsands problem, we'll have a shot at stopping it. The major city I live in, far from the tarsands, uses tarsands oil delivered here via pipelines. The refinery in the city causes much pollution, disease and death, as does the airport where much of the fuel ends up. Flying is a major use of oil and it comes from all the places we hope are soon shut down. Why would they stop, though? We're making them rich.

If we want to stop the tarsands development, we have to stop investing in it and, as much as possible, using it. Almost no one I know needs to fly. Environmentalists with frequent flier miles? Ridiculous. Most of us can probably cut our driving in half. We can stop buying so much stuff. But what we cannot do is stop the tarsands, the drilling the gulf, in the arctic, while using the product it provides us. We want it both ways. We're seeing the result. McKibbon seems to fly quite a bit. No reason for that anymore.

JPierre33

Why for me Idle No More:
-A response to a comment- @RedRider, your words: "...the entire basis for all this .....'Treaty rights' ..is based ....entirely on 'race'".
Uh huh....That's because "race" (your words) is the only place where you've been looking. For me that's not an issue but it clearly is to you since you are making it one.
My issue is with bills c-38 and c-45, in case you haven't heard of these. The legal treaties that First Nations have right now are the best chance of protecting the quality of our country and consequently, the quality of life not just for our selfish selves, but for our progeny. i.e. It's not a matter $$$ or market shares that are of value - that's a house of mirrors and cards. Quality is what gives anything real value.
I'm not saying that you mean to make it a "race" thing. I'm saying that you are choosing to make it so, perhaps inadvertently. Whether you are racist or not is irrelevant. What is relevant is the narrow perspective that results. And if you know me, as you claim you do, you'll know me more as a 'tree hugger'. Be that as it may. So, to make a point, your comments seem to reflect a presumed indignation that FNs are personally doing you wrong. Meanwhile, if you feel anything at all for this country, this planet, then you could look a bit deeper. You might just discover some things. For me that's been that the treaties are the strongest line of defense in preserving quality of life, not just here, but planet wise - perhaps you don't bother looking that far. (continues below)

Anonymous

Why are some human beings so god damn stereotypical. I am a native canadian .. Why do you's think we don't pay taxes? Get educated before you run your nonsense mouth. We do pay taxes thank you very much! I am from Ontario recently moved to Fort Mcmurray, Alberta .. Yes where the tarsands are and it does definitely give off tons of pollution. It is disgusting. Anyways, out here in Alberta my native status card is useless.. Does not save me 2-3$ at the grocery store or 10$ shopping for clothes like it would back home. Tax season, every year I always owe money probably just like everyone else. The government "lends" first nations money to put towards healthcare, education, jobs etc. So if first nations make a bingo hall, etc .. All that money has to get paid back to the gov't and then the money it makes afterwards goes to program funding. That is the way it works people. Educate yourself.

Pages

Add a new comment

To comment or reply please Log In, Create An Account or post as Anonymous.