Islamic Finance and the Possibility of Rebirth
With the financial markets in the gutter, and the trickle-down effect starting to be seen in many of our daily lives – friends and neighbors losing jobs (I especially see it around here in New York) – now seems like a good time to reflect on our financial culture here in the West.
A lot of us probably hate the idea of finance, think it's a sleazy profession motivated by greed. But in many ways the developments in finance in Europe over the past five hundred years have been a crucial part of our development, helping to make possible a huge array of innovations, from the first clothing factories in England at the end of the 18th century, to the development of the iPod at the end of the 20th. Despite the gains facilitated by finance, the benefits to society have always been coupled with a wild irregularity, a boom-bust cycle, which Marx described as part of the inherent contradictions of capitalism, contradictions which would eventually lead to its demise. We've never really grounded our financial ideas in solid principles, other than the sole one of making as much money as possible.
Perhaps there's another way. A shining example that has come out in the past fifty years, one that casts serious doubt on the Western no-holds-barred style, is the recent development of the principles of Islamic Finance. Based on Sharia law, which derives its authority from the Holy Qur'an, the principles of Islamic Finance have provided a beacon of clarity and common sense in good investment practices which are desperately needed here in the West.
What is at the core of the philosophy of Islamic Finance is the idea of money a measure of value, and not a real asset in itself. According to the principles of Islamic Finance, profiting from money–including charging interest on loans–is regarded as riba, or non-permissible investing activity under Sharia law. Instead, what Islamic Finance emphasizes is the idea that the investors should share the risks involved in whatever projects they are investing in, and that they should be investing in real things, whether it's land improvement projects, housing, or helping start up a new business. This represents a glaring difference from daily activities of investment firms in the West, who get huge returns by hacking variations in currency exchange rates, legally manipulating stock prices, and engaging in the kind of risk-spreading and avoiding activities (through an ever-increasing range of derivatives) that have created the huge mess we're in now.
We have to learn to differentiate between the legitimate function of finance, which is to provide money to start and expand a wide range of projects, and the activities that are really disconcerting: the hacking of the markets, currency trading, calls, puts, the entropic soup of Western instruments many of which do nothing, absolutely nothing to help start projects, nothing to help businesses stay afloat during the hard times and expand during the good, nothing to help people buy their first homes or first cars or, yes, even go to college. These do nothing at all except fatten the pockets of the financiers that carry them out. They're like skimming off the top of a huge pot of resources made from the commonwealth, from the work of people who make an honest living. And at the end of the day this "skimming" leaves everyone a little bit poorer, with a little bit less left in the pot, and it's a practice that really ought to provoke outrage.
At a time like this we need to start thinking about how to put real principles into the world of finance, ideals that are at the core of Islamic Finance and at the core of human decency.
In my idle time, I dream of the day when I can walk down Wall Street and see coffee shops, music halls, see kids busking on the street, see the hideous cigar store on Broad Street turned into a hangout space for artists and philosophers where they talk about the latest ideas and ideals while on break from the tedious job of handling finance. I dream of the day when flower vines grow over the grotesque naked buildings of the financial districts here and in London and in Tokyo and in Dubai, for the day when finance is again the pulsing heart of the coming Renaissance. I dream of the day when--as one of my friends put it--a tree grows from the New York Stock Exchange.
104 comments on the article “Islamic Finance and the Possibility of Rebirth”
Displaying 11 - 20 of 104
Page 2 of 11
G.Caratella
Great stuff!
Glad to see the ideas behind Islamic Finance are being recognized, also interesting to see the debate. For those who think you are promoting a religion (and there will be many others), maybe it should be called "Interest Free Banking" cos it cannot possibly be called "Middle Eastern" as the majority of the Middle East would probably prefer using the Capitalist system. In a perfect world, Interest Free Banking would be a great alternative, however unfortunately Human greed usually gets in the way....
G.Caratella
Great stuff!
Glad to see the ideas behind Islamic Finance are being recognized, also interesting to see the debate. For those who think you are promoting a religion (and there will be many others), maybe it should be called "Interest Free Banking" cos it cannot possibly be called "Middle Eastern" as the majority of the Middle East would probably prefer using the Capitalist system. In a perfect world, Interest Free Banking would be a great alternative, however unfortunately Human greed usually gets in the way....
Jeremy
I was talking about this just yesterday. It's interesting, because the Bible forbids usury too, and for all our talk of being Christian countries, we've completely ignored those principles. Time for a little humility I think, and to admit that we have some things to learn from Islam.
Jeremy
I was talking about this just yesterday. It's interesting, because the Bible forbids usury too, and for all our talk of being Christian countries, we've completely ignored those principles. Time for a little humility I think, and to admit that we have some things to learn from Islam.
Anonymous
The walls of the exchanges are running red with panic. Shares prices collapsing this morning along with shipping rates, commodity prices, even copper - which a few weeks ago gave us the urban legend of the penny in your pocket being worth more than its face value. Today, every copper penny in your pocket counts. Everyone is digging a financial bunker.
The Tehran stock market, however is apparently doing just fine. Which is nice for them. Buy Iranian preferred now to avoid disappointment - would seem to be the message. Or abandon the abominable hedonism of of usury. The Invisible Hand of the market writes; and, having writ, moves on indeed. The Market works in wondrous ways its good work to perform. It may look crazy to us, but trust them, the financial high priests know best, they will get us all out of this terrible mess if we only let them. Exactly as they always have.
Anonymous
The walls of the exchanges are running red with panic. Shares prices collapsing this morning along with shipping rates, commodity prices, even copper - which a few weeks ago gave us the urban legend of the penny in your pocket being worth more than its face value. Today, every copper penny in your pocket counts. Everyone is digging a financial bunker.
The Tehran stock market, however is apparently doing just fine. Which is nice for them. Buy Iranian preferred now to avoid disappointment - would seem to be the message. Or abandon the abominable hedonism of of usury. The Invisible Hand of the market writes; and, having writ, moves on indeed. The Market works in wondrous ways its good work to perform. It may look crazy to us, but trust them, the financial high priests know best, they will get us all out of this terrible mess if we only let them. Exactly as they always have.
anonymous
I agree that a finance system that deals with non-fictional values would be a welcome thing. The problem is just that there are always people that enjoy getting more money than others, and they will do it as long as there is no control over the finance system. That's what we used to have governments for, but most people forgot about that (remember, governments also used to be there to care about water, energy, education, ...).
But don't you think its quite a bad idea to suggest something that is based on rules that are sometimes interpreted as a system that promotes corporal punishment, execution and sexism? Nothing against taking ideals/ideas from Islam (but I believe these ideals are present in quite many religions). But the Sharia... have you actually read the wikipedia article (and its discussion) that you quoted? Its something thats worth as much of a discussion as the financial markets...
It's nice that you are getting your inspiration from religion. But maybe you can find some sound arguments that are based on values that everyone can share.
Let's value the work of philosophers and reformists since the early enlightenment and keep religion a private thing, seperated from state and law.
anonymous
I agree that a finance system that deals with non-fictional values would be a welcome thing. The problem is just that there are always people that enjoy getting more money than others, and they will do it as long as there is no control over the finance system. That's what we used to have governments for, but most people forgot about that (remember, governments also used to be there to care about water, energy, education, ...).
But don't you think its quite a bad idea to suggest something that is based on rules that are sometimes interpreted as a system that promotes corporal punishment, execution and sexism? Nothing against taking ideals/ideas from Islam (but I believe these ideals are present in quite many religions). But the Sharia... have you actually read the wikipedia article (and its discussion) that you quoted? Its something thats worth as much of a discussion as the financial markets...
It's nice that you are getting your inspiration from religion. But maybe you can find some sound arguments that are based on values that everyone can share.
Let's value the work of philosophers and reformists since the early enlightenment and keep religion a private thing, seperated from state and law.
edanto
Honestly, I think interest-free lending is a pretty stupid and completely impractical idea - how would you pay for the administration and tracking of loans?
The core message of the article seems to be how the system needs to be reformed. But there's a long road between the current profiteering system and interest-free loans.
Some ideas between the two extremes might be to restrict the types of financial products that are legal, to put in place a nonprofit international regulatory system with the power to fine corporations and a legal object to improve the conditions of all humanity via economics.
We need to connect and act in concert the way that the sociopathic corporations can and compete with them in an alternative ethical system that people will migrate to because they prefer.
I see the problem but not the solution.
edanto
Honestly, I think interest-free lending is a pretty stupid and completely impractical idea - how would you pay for the administration and tracking of loans?
The core message of the article seems to be how the system needs to be reformed. But there's a long road between the current profiteering system and interest-free loans.
Some ideas between the two extremes might be to restrict the types of financial products that are legal, to put in place a nonprofit international regulatory system with the power to fine corporations and a legal object to improve the conditions of all humanity via economics.
We need to connect and act in concert the way that the sociopathic corporations can and compete with them in an alternative ethical system that people will migrate to because they prefer.
I see the problem but not the solution.
Pages
Add a new comment